Skip to Navigation
stop an argument

There’s a point in an argument at which the arguers lose sight of what the original dispute was about. From then on it is what I call a meta-argument; and argument about an argument, rather than a fight or dispute about whatever the difference was that caused it.

In a meta-argument the disputants attack the way they are fighting, rather than what they are fighting about. The focus will be on things like  tactics (unfair or indecent), character (flawed), history (respective versions of), and relevance (to other arguments).

This is when arguing gets serious. There can be no solution to a meta-argument by doing more of it; it will rumble on, sometimes to the point of not return. But there is a way out:

  • Recognise when the argument has become about winning or destroying the other person, rather than reaching agreement
  • Call a halt, but be sure to explain that you are not walking away from the disagreement – which needs discussing and resolving – but from the WAY you are both going about it (and take responsibility for your part in that)
  • Re-schedule a discussion where you start by agreeing what the dispute is actually about. Use simple language like “We disagree on parenting styles”, “We have different views about how a job should be done”, or “We not happy about ‘X’ and we want ‘Y'”.

If you can agree on what you disagree on, and agree on what matters to you both, you’ll be discussing the ‘how’ of the disagreement, rather than the ‘what’.

This is a great starting point, and as responsible and respectful adults you’ll be able to manage from there on.

 

What do you think? Share your thoughts...

Latest from the blog

Simple Solutions Are Best

Faced with a dilemma? Here’s how to choose.

Continue reading

What makes effective staff training?

Organisatons spend millions each year on staff training yet much of it is a waste of money. One pundit recently claimed that people only remember 16% of what they are taught in training. Would any organisation buy another product or service that only worked 16% of the time?

Continue reading

Why Can’t I Help Myself When I Hear a Question?

We can become powerless in the face of the questions we are asked. Why is this? What provokes us to unthinkingly accept that a question MUST be answered, then and there, just because it is a question?

Well formed questions are a powerful and delightful thing. Badly formed ones are often the last resort of bigots and bamboozlers.

Even when its not that serious, we let ourselves down when we use questions carelessly.

Continue reading
FREE DOWNLOAD - Get it now.

How to be more Resilient

Get my super-helpful guide '9 Steps to Resilience' absolutely FREE, when you subscribe to my newsletter.

Understand the steps to resilience and you can develop the ability to cope with problems and setbacks with less stress and more confidence.
close-link
%d bloggers like this: