Skip to Navigation

There is an important difference between having a conscience and feeling guilty.

Being guided by your conscience means understanding right and wrong (according to your own value system). This is what helps correct us when we have, or are about to act in a way which would conflict with our values, or those of society.

Feeling guilty, on the other hand, can result in neurotic self-blaming which serves no useful purpose.

Good news about guilty feelings

The ability to feel guilty is a useful part of our social evolution. We are a social species and shame, guilt and fear of discovery of our errors would naturally help keep us in line and discourage us from committing them. The good news about guilt, is that it is the flip-side of social awareness; If you feel guilty it means that you have a conscience.

When guilty feelings are a nuisance

But there’s also the sort of nagging and pervasive guilt that blights many people’s lives. Guilt may be a necessary emotion, but it quickly becomes redundant when it makes itself a nuisance, by giving us intrusive and upsetting feelings that don’t seem to be tied to anything specific that we’ve done.

With this sort of guilt, we don’t think we have anything to feel guilty about, but we get the guilty feelings anyway. In extreme cases, we’ll apologise when there’s nothing to say sorry for. Eventually, a pervasive and nagging sense of guilt can start to shape our behaviour, our beliefs about ourselves, and even our character.

Breaking the cycle

To break this painful cycle you must first recognise the problem for what it is. Examine the feelings and challenge the logic that keeps them alive. This can be tricky because guilt will fight back with all sorts of counter-arguments (it can even make you feel guilty about wanting to be guilt-free).

Healing starts with an acceptance that unhealthy guilty feelings are unjustified and that you can be free of them. You may not believe it or think you deserve it, but that just how guilt keeps you stuck with it.

My online course – How to Be Free of Guilt

2 Responses to “Guilty Feelings vs Conscience”

  1. Coincidentally, I was reading a very funny passage in Tristram Shandy the other day where this very subject was aired. I recommend that novel if only for the discussion on conscience. In brief, the message is that conscience itself does not tell you what should be done; it just nudges you to do it the ethical frame of reference being somewhere else.
    Secondly, whenever I hear anyone say “Oooh, I feel sooooo guilty …” it often means [too often] it is a smoke screen for having avoided a responsibility. It says: “I know I should have done that but, d’you know what, I couldn’t be bothered but I can obfuscate my lack of responsibility by pretending that I fee guilty. If I feel guilty, I won’t have to feel guilty in public and that’s a great excuse for not behaving responsibly”

What do you think? Share your thoughts...

Latest from the blog

Personal Calvary, and Chocolate

There are two types of people in the world, I’ve been told; those that can eat a bar of chocolate one piece at a time, and those who don’t even bother trying. The latter group have no brakes, and ‘sharing’ isn’t in their vocabulary (should that be vocadbury?*). There are two types when it comes […]

Continue reading

Brief Therapy for Depression

Most depressions can be cured or substantially alleviated yet we still pretend that they can’t. Hand-wringing and attempts at sympathy don’t help, enlightenment and common understanding will. Treatment guidelines are explicit, brief problem-solving talk-therapy is a proven treatment.
We should be accepting and treating depression as the common ailment it is, not shrouding it in mystery and pretending that we don’t know what to do about it.

Continue reading

How to Adjust to Change


Resisting change is not only a waste of time, it also makes it harder to deal with. Following advice from other people is probably not the right way to go either (you can still read this though).

Change can be difficult, but it needn’t be as big a problem as we often make it.

Continue reading
FREE DOWNLOAD - Get it now.

How to be more Resilient

Get my super-helpful guide '9 Steps to Resilience' absolutely FREE, when you subscribe to my newsletter.

Understand the steps to resilience and you can develop the ability to cope with problems and setbacks with less stress and more confidence.
%d bloggers like this: